For my version, I purchased the following from:
WalMart: frame for $0.97 and notepad
Hobby Lobby: all paper, ribbon, Stickles
Dollar General: Pentel brand pen (WalMart carries these as well)
JoAnn: circle and scalloped punches
I used my Cricut and the Happy Hauntings cartridge for the witch hat and boots. The sentiment was computer generated using WrapCandy.
Did you notice the barrel of the pen? I wrapped some of the stipped paper (like I used for the witch's stockings) around it. I saw this idea on Splitcoaststampers as well.
I hope you have an awesome day and Happy Scrappin'! Carol :)